Have you read Gethsemane: Reflections on the Contemporary Theological Movement by Cardinal Siri and/or Vatican II Revisited: Reflections by One Who Was There by Bishop Aloysius Wycislo? Is Card. Siri's work the best assessment of post-Vatican II theological errors? Viz., is Card. Siri's work reflective of him being to post-Vatican II what Fr. Garrigou-Lagrange was for pre-Vatican II? Cf. this. Thanks

Alan, I'd like to read Siri's book, but even secondhand it's $80+!

My copy is coming via interlibrary loan.

The prologue of Msgr. Gherardini's recent book, Vatican II: A Much-Needed Discussion (I think that's the English title.), mentions Card. Siri's work alongside Amerio's Iota Unum. I wonder if Iota Unum superseded Gethsemane, and if Msgr. Gherardini's work, being more recent, has in a way superseded all the preceding Vatican II works? From what I have read of it so far, it is very good.

My Italian interlibrary-loaned version of Siri's book is not copyrighted, so I'm going to scan it. It seems very good. I'm also interlibrary-loaning the English version; perhaps it isn't copyrighted either because it, too, comes from the same publisher.

There is a French version online
http://www.scribd.com/doc/92582835/Siri ... Gethsemani

A PDF of the Italian original version can be downloaded here.

Having begun this work, I find his treatment of Rahner rather soft…